Butterfly Rebellion

 

The original Photo from Archives http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/205194967

David Halliday Wings Acolyte and Propagandist

David Halliday  likes to continually slag off BBC Scotland News yet his bidie in Girlfriend reads exactly the same News for STV News programmes. BBC News Bad, STV News good. Pitiful.

Richard Murphy Another Propagandist Galslighter deliberately playing Scots for complete Fools

Richard Murphy once again being exposed as a fool and deliberate deceiver of "Useful Idiot " Scots Nationalists  See the Thread here Richard Muphy gets Schooled on Truthful Economics

Here also we have Richard Murphy seen reading two completely different financial reports  produced in two different financial Years and doesn't even understand he is doing so or why he cannot get the numbers to match , he then goes and writes a conspiracy blog for Scottish Nationalists on why the numbers don't match and blames the UK Government for it instead of his own stupidity and  sloppy Schoolboy error in not understanding he was comparing different sets of data and from even two completely different years.

The Scottish Parliaments own Video clip with Murphy can be see on the links below , it clearly exposes him as a complete buffoon and Murphy is finally forced to admit at Holyrood himself that he did NOT do ANY proper research on Scotlands numbers at all and simply made up his own false propaganda instead.

https://www.scottishparliament.tv/meeting/economy-jobs-and-fair-work-committee-september-19-2017?clip_start=11:06:46&clip_end=11:16:13

The same clip also available on youtube here https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=9&v=Ni5dTPBgLKE

=====================================================================

Richard Murphy getting shown to be a fool on Scot Gov GERS figures, Nats will cling on to any clown who tells them a story they really want to hear ...gullible suckers.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lz2rmglHGFU&feature=youtu.be

Richard Murphy once again taken apart of financial facts yet still clings onto trying to hand onto his assertion "GERS massively flawed" by pointing to minor parts of data which make little difference to the GERs reports ...desperately clutching at straws
https://twitter.com/FraserWhyte81/status/904757673807286275

And more from the papers  http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/politics/economic-facts-become-snps-enemy-11124265.amp


 Member of Sturgeon Fan club
http://www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2017/03/17/the-two-most-powerful-politicians-in-the-uk/


Fraser of Allander (University of Strathclyde Economists)

All about GERS Part1 https://fraserofallander.org/2017/08/17/next-weeks-gers-numbers-part-1/
and Part 2 https://fraserofallander.org/2017/08/18/next-weeks-gers-numbers-part-2/

=====================================================================

GERS  Data was used to build the SNP's own 2014 White Paper for Indyref and other Scot Gov official documents.

=======================================================

Richard Murphy "Tax Advisor " (not an economist)  gets a drubbing here from Economics Professor Simon Wren Lewis  (Emeritus Professor of Economics and Fellow of Merton College, University of Oxford)

https://mainlymacro.blogspot.com/2018/08/labours-fiscal-rule-is-progressive.html?m=1

Which brings me to Richard Murphy’s post

. Richard says so many false things about this rule it is difficult to know where to start. It is not ‘neoclassical’, it does not ‘have its roots in microeconomics’. It does not assume ‘markets allocate resources efficiently’. It does not make any assumptions about how money is created. To say that Labour’s rule is based on a microeconomics perspective but MMT has a macro perspective is complete and utter nonsense. You can justify Labour’s rule on the basis of pretty well any macroeconomics you like, as long as you accept that interest rates are stabilising the economy rather than fiscal policy.

The bottom line is that Richard tries to suggest that you could have more public spending under an MMT type assignment compared to Labour’s fiscal rule. That is also completely wrong, and if anything the opposite would be true. Suppose Labour comes to power in 2022, and nominal interest rates by then are at 2%, and inflation is steady at target. Labour are pledged to substantially increase public investment spending (which is outside the rule), which will put upward pressure on demand, at least initially. That would mean under a conventional assignment interest rates would rise to prevent inflation. But in an MMT world that wouldn’t happen. So in an MMT world how do you stop inflation rising? Either current spending would have to be cut, or taxes increased.

There is only one way that public spending for given taxes could be higher in an MMT world compared to Labour’s fiscal rule, and that is if inflation was not controlled at all. That is not what serious MMT economists would recommend. So when Richard says Labour’s rule means a Labour government would be committed to austerity policies, by which I think he means low public spending, while his MMT alternative would allow more public spending without raising taxes, he is, once again, just wrong.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

#Richard Murphy

#Tax Research UK 


#Tax Research

#Professor Richard Murphy

#Professor Murphy

#The Joy of Tax

Cliff Serbie...There surely is madness here ?

This below surely can only be the work of a deluded madman ?

The True Annual Figures are available from our own
Scottish Government Website here https://www.gov.scot/Publications/2017/08/7201


SNP Scot Governments own Website says "Scotland raised £5b8bn but spent £71bn on providing Scottish Public Services ,,an overspend (Deficit) of £13bn annually , yet Serbie spreads made up rubbish like this below around..clearly not "intelligent " or "well informed " at all. 

"The Scottish Government's Chief Statistician takes responsibility for this publication"

http://www.gov.scot/Topics/Statistics/Browse/Economy/GERS

===============================================================

If there ever was anything that demonstrated Cliff Serbie is just a moron.....

Wee Ginger Dug a barking mad Nationalist False Propaganda writer

More Wee Ginger Dug Invented lies seen here Lies , Damned Lies and Accounting tricks





The latest Nationalist Lying Propagandist moneyraiser trick..."pay for my Wedding" and all my own other lifestyle choices.

======================================================================

The Wee Ginger Lying Dugs invented crap is exposed for all to see on the Freedom of Information Request return below, despite the Lying Gingers Dugs assertion that " The Scottish Government has a legal obligation to produce the GERS figures " the Scottish Government itself says this is simply a Lie , there is NO legal obligation to publish GERS or any of its other produced statistics.

So once again just proven Lies from a Nationalist invented propaganda generator who has no actual factual real knowledge to offer anyone other than his own invented fantasy garbage.

==============================================================

======================================================================

None, Zero, Nada, Zilch  http://chokkablog.blogspot.co.uk/2016/07/unknown-region-exports-hidden-gdp.html



More exposing of the WeeWhingingDugs made up fantasy Lies  on the link below
http://www.thinkscotland.org/todays-thinking/articles.html?read_full=13123&article=www.thinkscotland.org

================================================================

Paul Kavanaghs latest attempt to spread more of his invented conspiracy theorist made up rubbish on the link below, this man really needs to go and get some psychotherapy or counselling for whatever his mental problem is ...or is he simply  knowingly and deliberately making up this rubbish to deceive as many others as he can to hold on to those people who are unable to see what a Narcissist and who cannot hide his desire to be "worshipped" no matter how many lies he has to tell to get his personal fix of "Adoration" from the pool of "useful Idiots" swimming in the Nationalist Seas ?

https://weegingerdug.wordpress.com/2018/02/11/why-the-indy-movement-needs-to-crowdfund/



















#Yessnp #Yes #Wee Ginger Dug   #Ginger Dug   #Paul Kavanagh   

Gordon McIntyre Kemp the SNP Business for Scotland False Propaganda writer

23/5/2018 McIntyre-Kemp gets shredded on TV again discussing the SNP's Growth Commission Report 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NzP8kdPP7w8

================================================================


25/01/2017 The writer of made up propaganda for "Business for Scotland" Gordon McIntyre Kemp gets destroyed on currency and exports on Scotland Tonight by Kevin Hague see on the link below
                          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T4YEdW1urdc

THE founder and chief executive of the pro-independence group Business for Scotland has admitted losing “a significant amount of money” after his sole business venture was wound up.

Gordon Macintyre-Kemp, who is behind a new fundraising campaign for a second referendum, put more than £50,000 into a social media consultancy that ended with net assets of £594.

Intelligise Limited, which was based at Mr Macintyre-Kemp’s home in Jordanhill in Glasgow, was “dissolved via voluntary strike-off” in February 2016, the Herald can reveal. See Article Here

More of Gordon's made up propaganda rubbish picked apart below 

1   Deutsche Bank Report   http://chokkablog.blogspot.co.uk/2015/02/business-for-scotland-deutsche-bank.html

2  Oil Price and Scottish Tax Generation http://chokkablog.blogspot.co.uk/2015/04/oil-price-and-scottish-tax-generation.html

3   Independence and the Economy   http://chokkablog.blogspot.co.uk/2014/07/response-to-independence-and-economy.html

4   £8.3bn Better off  http://chokkablog.blogspot.co.uk/2014/08/83bn-better-off.html  

5   The Oil crash is Good  (120 Thousand jobs have been lost in Scotlands Oil Industry FFS )  https://whytepaper.wordpress.com/2016/03/09/the-oil-crash-is-good-for-the-overall-economy-and-gordon-macintyre-kemps-deficit-deception/

If you actually believe Kemp's spin in his made up lies then you must be a gullible fool, so think hard about them. http://rwbblog.blogspot.co.uk/2017/01/hail-mary.html
====================================================================

 Business for Scotland labelled itself as "independent and political party neutral " which is simply a ridiculous farce when they have been exposed as simply an SNP front for false propaganda . see more on link here
http://chokkablog.blogspot.co.uk/2016/05/business-for-scotland-where-are-they-now.html

Business for Scotlands "propagandist in chief " is Gordon MacIntyre Kemp who also writes propaganda for the SNP's Nationalist Fanzine "The National" Newspaper ,another source of mostly "made up " or manipulated facts to further the goals of Scottish Nationalism and to attack Westminster wherever possible. Goebbels himself would have been proud of the work attempted in the "National". Rather Ironic don't you think for Gordon to be talking of "narrow-minded insular national agendas" when his own job is to actually write false articles to pursue those very same goals ?

McIntyre-Kemp turns £50K of his own money into £500.  Yep... £500.
Click for article here

More on Business for Scotland here
http://chokkablog.blogspot.co.uk/2016/05/business-for-scotland-where-are-they-now.html
====================================================================

MacIntyre-Kemp the false propagandist caught providing misinformation or deliberate lies once again

Soon debunked once again by Kevin Hague 

 "Business for Scotland " is a group that exists to deceive Scotland with complex made up Lies"

====================================================================

20 August 2017 The original Sunday Heralds Full Zoomer article again written by McIntyre-Kemp.

"Westminster's Scotland Oil Lies"  Click here                                         Archived

20 August 2017 :  See Chris Deering taking apart the latest McIntyre-Kemps latest
invented Sunday Herald  fantasy right here                                               Archived

22 August 2017 : Kevin Hague's clearly explained Blog on the fantasy Business for Scotland McIntyre-Kemp written Sunday Herald piece  Click here to read blog      Archived

23 August 2017 : Amazingly one embarrassing bruising wasn't enough and McIntyre-Kemp has come back with another post truth piece of writing not only denying his previous delusion but trying to re-inforce it. Click here for article                                                           Archived
 

#Growth Commission    #SNP Growth Commission   

#BBCScotland   #Cybernats   #Goebbels  

#Business for Scotland  #Gordon MacIntyre Kemp #Gordon MacIntyre-Kemp

#£8bn Better Off
#£8bn Better Off ?

#£8bn better off ?

#Independent Scotland £8bn better off ?

#Would an Independent Scotland be £8bn better off ?

#Deutsche Bank Report

#£8.3bn better off ?

#£8.3bn Better Off

#Indyref


#Scotref

#theintellegiser